Group Homes vs Traditional Rentals: Which Earns More?

Are you earning as much as you could from your rental property? If you’re a landlord or real estate investor exploring higher-yield strategies, it’s time to consider the group home model. With the potential for 30–50% profit margins and reduced vacancy risk, converting a single-family rental into a group home could be your most lucrative move yet.

Traditional Rental: Income and Limitations

Let’s consider a standard 4-bedroom single-family rental. In most markets, you might charge $2,000/month. After property taxes, insurance, maintenance, and management fees, your net profit might land around $400–$600/month—roughly a 10–15% margin.

Case Example

  • Monthly Rent: $2,000
  • Expenses: $1,400
  • Net Profit: $600
  • Vacancy Risk: 100% if tenant moves out

Group Home Model: How the Income Adds Up

Now, imagine that same 4-bedroom home is licensed or operated as a group home for 5 high-functioning adults. Each resident pays $800/month. That’s $4,000/month in gross revenue.

Group Home Case Example

  • Monthly Revenue: $4,000
  • Expenses (including utilities, basic management): $2,000
  • Net Profit: $2,000
  • Profit Margin: 50%
  • Vacancy Risk: Losing one resident = 80% occupancy

Rental vs Group Home: Side-by-Side Comparison

Metric Traditional Rental Group Home
Monthly Revenue $2,000 $4,000
Monthly Expenses $1,400 $2,000
Net Profit $600 $2,000
Profit Margin 30% 50%
Vacancy Risk High Lower

What It Takes to Convert to a Group Home

Converting a home doesn’t always require major renovation. For homes serving high-functioning adults, the setup can resemble a boarding house. You may not need 24/7 staff—just a property manager or house coordinator. Some investors self-manage, others hire help.

Key Considerations

  • Local zoning and licensing rules
  • Minor modifications for safety or accessibility
  • Tenant screening and house rules
  • Optional support staff depending on resident needs

Why the Effort is Worth It

Yes, there’s more to manage. But the financial upside—and the social good—make it worthwhile. You’re not just increasing your income; you’re providing stable housing for those who need it.

Interested in this strategy? Sign up for our free webinar to hear how investors are doubling rental income with group homes.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Do I need a background in caregiving to run a group home?

No. Many group homes serve high-functioning adults and operate similarly to shared housing or boarding homes.

2. How do I find residents for my group home?

You can partner with local agencies, nonprofits, or list your home on specialized housing platforms.

3. Is licensing required?

It depends on your state and the population you serve. Some group homes operate without formal licensing if no medical care is provided.

4. What are typical monthly expenses?

Expect $1,500–$2,500 depending on utilities, food (if provided), and staffing. Expenses are offset by higher rent per resident.

5. Can I finance a property with this model?

Yes. Many lenders approve standard mortgages. Once operating, your group home’s income can support future financing.

6. How much time does it take to manage?

With systems in place, it can be similar to managing a standard rental—especially if you hire a coordinator or property manager.

author avatar
brandon